While Charlie was in the hospital recovering from the surgery, the nurse gave her opinion of the experiment: "Maybe they got no rite to make me smart because if god wantid me to be smart he would have made me born that way. And what about Adem and Eev and the sin with the tree of knowlege and eating the appel and the fall. And mabey Prf Nemur and Dr Strauss was tampiring with the things they got no rite to tampir with."
What is your opinion? Should doctors and scientists tamper with intelligence?
Please answer in at least one paragraph.
I don't think doctors and scientists should tamper with intelligence because if Charlie wants to be smart, he can try harder and learn more at school. There are many things that could go wrong in the operation and it might not work or Charlie might become less intelligent than he was before the operation. Even if they experimented with an animal before, humans are different. Doctors and scientists should leave people how they are and then they can really only get smarter.
ReplyDeleteI think that the doctors and scientists should not make people intelligent. If Charlie wanted to be intelligent then he should have read more so he could learn how to spell. Animals and people are not the same, Charlie didn't know what happened to Algernon when he got the surgery done to him. I would have said no because the surgery could have made you really sick and they warned you about it. You wouldn't know how sick it would actually get you though. If people want to be smart they would try to be smart instead of having surgery to make them smart.
ReplyDeleteIn a way I think that it would be great for people like Charlie to be able to do what everyone else does and know what everyone else knows. But I think that it is wrong for science to mess with what was given to him by God. I mean If God wanted him to be smart he would have made him smart. I also think it is wrong because Charlie really didn't know what he was getting himself into.
ReplyDeleteI think that it can go both ways. He is smart in his own way and does not exactly have to have the operation. it is also a great contribution to science tho and can have many benifits. he has to choose of what he wants in his life and not what other people want.
ReplyDelete